Beneath the waves off New Zealand's coast lies a hidden history—a watery graveyard of over 2,500 sunken ships, each holding secrets and stories waiting to be uncovered. But here's the catch: these underwater time capsules are under threat.
Recent reports have surfaced, sparking concern that one of New Zealand's most famous shipwrecks, the S.S. Tasmania, is being plundered by divers. Are they modern-day pirates seeking lost treasures, or simply enthusiasts collecting souvenirs? The debate is heated, and the truth may be murkier than the depths themselves.
The S.S. Tasmania, a majestic passenger steamer, met its fate in 1897 during a ferocious storm off Table Cape. Among its cargo was a suitcase belonging to a Rothschild relative, brimming with jewels—rubies, opals, sapphires, and diamonds. Diving legend Kelly Tarlton, drawn by the allure of this treasure, purchased the wreck's rights in the 1970s and recovered around 250 jewel-encrusted rings and other artifacts. Yet, this was just a fraction of the bounty; more than half of the treasure remains lost, buried beneath the shifting sands and currents.
And this is where it gets even more intriguing: Despite the allure of untold riches, experts agree that the remaining treasure is likely beyond reach. Storms, strong currents, and sediment from land clearances have transformed the site into a muddy, inaccessible maze. Still, the wreck continues to attract attention, not just from treasure hunters but also from fishermen seeking prized catches that gather around the artificial reef created by the sunken ship.
Some divers, however, are suspected of seeking more than fish. Crockery, historical artifacts, and other remnants of the past are believed to be their targets. But not everyone agrees that looting is occurring. Garth MacIntyre, a seasoned diver and owner of the property closest to the wreck, offers a different perspective. With 50 years of experience and Kelly Tarlton as one of his mentors, MacIntyre believes the site is primarily visited by recreational divers and spear fishermen, drawn by the wreck's vibrant marine life and stunning underwater scenery.
Here's the controversial part: MacIntyre argues that treasure hunting is more of a passion than a profitable venture. 'You're not going to get rich out of it,' he says. The real treasure, according to him, lies in the history and stories of those who sailed on these ships. New Zealand's relatively young history means that many of these wrecks are well-documented, yet the thrill of discovering and documenting them remains unparalleled. With advancements in technology, these underwater discoveries can now be shared with the public, fueling the passion of divers like MacIntyre and his team.
Today on The Detail, MacIntyre delves deeper into the laws governing diving around shipwrecks and the complexities of salvage rights. But here's the question that lingers: Are these divers preserving history or pilfering it? What do you think? Is treasure hunting a harmless pursuit or a threat to our underwater heritage? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
To listen to the full discussion and stay updated, check out The Detail here: https://linktr.ee/thedetailnz. And don’t forget to follow us on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/TheDetailRNZ/ and Twitter https://x.com/thedetailnz for more captivating stories.
